|Contact us Subscribe to newsletter Search|
Eva Haukeland Fredriksen is a physiotherapist and sociologist. She is a lecturer at the Department of Physiotherapy in Bergen and does clinical work part-time. From January 2007 she has been a PhD student at the Faculty of Medicine at the University of Oslo,
Her doctoral project “Pregnant: Ill/healthy/strong/weak?”
The study is presented in the article "'Listen to your body' A qualitative text analysis of internet discussions related to pregnancy health and pelvic girdle pain in pregnancy" which is co-written with the supervisors Karen Marie Moland and Johanne Sundby. It is published in the November issue of the periodical Patient Education and Counseling.
The study is financed by The Norwegian Women’s Public Health Association (Norske Kvinners Sanitetsforening).
Listen to your body
The health authorities claim that pelvic girdle pain is a common complaint during pregnancy. Pregnant women online take it a bit more seriously.
You are 22 weeks pregnant. Your tailbone hurts and your back is stiff. Does this mean that you are suffering from pelvic girdle pain?
This question is taken from the Norwegian website barnimagen.com (child in womb). For years there has been an ongoing online debate on pelvic girdle pain (PGP). The discussion has been followed for one year and was used as the basis for a study.
Physiotherapist and sociologist Eva Haukeland Fredriksen has analysed how women discuss pelvic pain and how they cope with these problems on the website barnimagen.com. (Illustration.: istockphoto.com)
Physiotherapist and sociologist Eva Haukeland Fredriksen has analysed how women discuss pelvic girdle pain and how they cope with it. She has compared her findings to how the health authorities and research present this condition.
According to her findings there is a big gap in how women on the Internet and the health authorities look at PGP. Whereas the Norwegian Guidelines for Pregnancy Care define PGP as a common complaint in pregnancy which on rare occasions may develop into a serious condition, pregnant women online are far more concerned with the fact that pelvic pain may develop into a serious health problem.
– Pelvic girdle pain is surrounded by dramatic stories and many women who experience vague symptoms join the Internet discussion worried that they are suffering from PGP, Fredriksen says. She is surprised at how worried the women are about PGP.
– I didn’t know how common it was, she comments.
The different views on PGP are also reflected in how pregnant women are met by their doctors, and the women online often state that they don’t feel that their problems are being taken seriously.
The study is presented in the latest edition of the international periodical Patient Education and Counseling. The debate Fredriksen has analysed is from 2005, but she believes her findings are equally relevant today. Fredriksen says that pelvic girdle pain is still a topic on the website and that pregnant women with health issues complain that they don’t feel they are being heard.
The hormonal changes during a pregnancy affect the ligaments and joints in the pelvis. They become softer and the pelvic joints become more flexible. This is to make the pelvis able to expand during child birth. For most women this process takes place without any problems, but some experience pain and reduced mobility. The reason for this is still unclear.
– Many women with vague symptoms who join the discussion worry that they are suffering from PGP, Fredriksen says. (Illustration: www.colourbox.no)
Each year around 30 Norwegian women end up on disability pension due to prolonged and serious PGP. Although very few are badly affected Fredriksen says that many of the women on barnimagen.com are worried that their problems will become more severe if they don’t take them seriously.
– The women want to identify the symptoms at an early stage in order to get help and treatment as soon as possible, she explains.
The women turn to the Internet discussion for support. Many of them write about their own experiences and use these as the basis for the advice that they give others.
In contrast with the official view on PGP as a ”common complaint” many of the women who participate in the Internet discussion see this as an unpredictable and potentially disabling condition.
– Pelvic girdle pain belongs to a group of subjective conditions which amongst others include fibromyalgia. There is an ongoing debate as to how it should be diagnosed and international research is divergent, Fredriksen explains.
PGP has received an increasing amount of attention over the last years and even though this condition can be found among women on all continents it is also described as a cultural-specific phenomenon, with the Scandinavian countries reporting of the highest number of cases. Due to unclear classification criteria it is difficult to compare the prevalence of this condition with other countries.
– According to the Norwegian Guidelines for Pregnancy Care from 2005, which refers to recent research, the prevalence of pelvic girdle pain is 20 percent, of which five percent are considered serious cases. But in a Norwegian survey from 1989 42 percent of the women reported of pelvic pain during their pregnancy. Whether the woman is diagnosed with PGP or not depends on the criteria that are used and on what the doctors consider as normal complaints during a pregnancy.
Problems with being heard
According to Fredriksen the uncertainty with regard to the pain worries the women. Many of them are tired and over-worked and there is a continuing discussion as to how much they should endure before they take sick leave. In many cases the doctors don’t share their view on their health condition and they feel that they are not being heard when they talk about their problems. After all, they are just pregnant, and pregnancy is not a disease.
The women online respond by supporting each other as credible and responsible mothers.
– The welfare of the baby is used to justify that the women are taking it easy. They don’t want to be perceived as immoral women who take sick leave for no reason but as responsible mothers who are looking out for themselves and the baby, Fredriksen says.
In many cases the doctors don’t share their view on their health condition and they feel that they are not being heard when they talk about their problems. (Illustration: iStockphoto)
She believes that the focus on PGP partly reflects the society’s lack of understanding for the needs of pregnant women and asks if this is a reaction to the contemporary discourse of pregnancy as a “normal condition”. Maybe it is too much to work full-time and have the main responsibility as care-givers at home while going through a pregnancy. The descriptions of PGP as an unpredictable condition may contribute to justify the needs of the woman to get more rest.
Fredriksen says it is worth noticing that around 60 percent of pregnant women in Norway are on sick leave for parts of their pregnancy even though this is considered a normal condition for women.
More emphasis on reproductive work
Fredriksen’s research reveals diverging views on PGP and a gap between the official policy on pregnancy health and the women’s own experiences. She wants policy-makers and the health care system to take these aspects into consideration.
– In my opinion, we must focus more on the reproductive work that a pregnancy is and be more attentive to pregnant women’s need for rest and support. This is a need that among other things is expressed in the Internet discussions.
Translated by: Vigdis Isachsen.
5 last articles
Rich boys more competitive in economic experiments
Why do we make the choices that we do? Are we born this way or have we become this way? Behavioural economists look for answers through economic and math experiments in the laboratory.(23.06.2014) Read more
FGM-politics based on emotions, not facts
Both female genital mutilation and forced marriage became part of the political agenda in Norway as a result of media publicity. According to a new report from Fafo, measures against female genital mutilation in particular are not based on knowledge and have been blown out of proportion.(10.06.2014) Read more
Gender blind research on innovation
Are new ideas primarily shaped within male dominated industries? Due to gender stereotypes, some businesses are valued more than others, claims Norwegian researcher.(27.05.2014) Read more
Class more important than gender for school performance
There is no doubt that boys and girls perform differently at school. But simply looking at gender in order to understand why is not enough.(12.05.2014) Read more
Gender equality politics cause problems when minority families meet the Child Welfare Service
Parents with minority background are perceived as second-rate parents compared to the Child Welfare Service’s ideals regarding Norwegian gender equality.(30.04.2014) Read more
KILDEN, Stensberggata 25 , NO-0170 Oslo, Phone: +47 22 03 80 80, E-mail: email@example.com